Maya Corrigan
  • Home
  • Bio
  • Writings
    • By Cook or by Crook
    • Scam Chowder
    • Final Fondue
    • The Tell-Tale Tarte
    • S'more Murders
    • Crypt Suzette
    • Gingerdead Man
    • Book Club Topics
    • Stories and Nonfiction
  • Mystery 101
    • Mystery Milestones
    • Detective Story Origins
    • Mystery Fashions
    • Edgar Allan Poe
    • Poe, Dickens, and Ravens
    • Poe and Lincoln
    • Holmes and Dracula
    • Christie's Clues
    • A.A. Milne's Mysteries
    • Poe Trivia Quiz
    • Christie Trivia Quiz
    • Sleuthing Sweethearts Quiz
    • Girl Mysteries
  • Food
    • Candy Corn's Haunted History
    • Chowder in History and Literature
    • Gingerbread's Dark History
    • Pie's Peculiar Past
    • S'mores History
    • Short Story: Delicious Death
    • Recipes >
      • Five-Ingredient Main Dishes
      • Easy Pies and Tarts
      • Six Sweet Recipes
      • Gingerbread Cookie Recipe
  • News/Events
  • SmorgasBlog
  • Home
  • Bio
  • Writings
    • By Cook or by Crook
    • Scam Chowder
    • Final Fondue
    • The Tell-Tale Tarte
    • S'more Murders
    • Crypt Suzette
    • Gingerdead Man
    • Book Club Topics
    • Stories and Nonfiction
  • Mystery 101
    • Mystery Milestones
    • Detective Story Origins
    • Mystery Fashions
    • Edgar Allan Poe
    • Poe, Dickens, and Ravens
    • Poe and Lincoln
    • Holmes and Dracula
    • Christie's Clues
    • A.A. Milne's Mysteries
    • Poe Trivia Quiz
    • Christie Trivia Quiz
    • Sleuthing Sweethearts Quiz
    • Girl Mysteries
  • Food
    • Candy Corn's Haunted History
    • Chowder in History and Literature
    • Gingerbread's Dark History
    • Pie's Peculiar Past
    • S'mores History
    • Short Story: Delicious Death
    • Recipes >
      • Five-Ingredient Main Dishes
      • Easy Pies and Tarts
      • Six Sweet Recipes
      • Gingerbread Cookie Recipe
  • News/Events
  • SmorgasBlog

Agatha Christie: Clues and Surprise Endings


Portrait of Agatha Christie
Agatha Christie puts murder on the menu
Along with millions of other mystery readers, I’ve smacked my head at the end of Agatha Christie’s books and thought, “I should have figured out who the murderer was. All the clues were there.”

How does Dame Agatha pull off a surprise ending time and again while playing fair with the reader? Three of her strategies for putting us off the scent begin with the letter "s"--Sidetracks, Stereotypes, and Sympathy.
Sidetracks
Christie leaves the clues in plain sight, yet sets us off on the wrong track. The victim’s purse contains keys on two key rings, a lipstick, theater tickets, and sunglasses. One person asks, “Why wouldn’t she put all the keys on the same ring?” Another points to the tickets: “Who went with her to the theater?” With attention drawn to the keys and the tickets, we forget the other items. A hundred pages later, a character no sooner comments that the victim never wore lipstick than a scream leads to the discovery of another body. The dramatic event overshadows the second lipstick clue. 
Two keyrings, lipstick, two theater tickets, sunglasses
Keys, tickets, lipstick, glasses
Stereotypes 
​

Dame Agatha counts on her readers for stereotypical reactions. We assume the innocence of certain types of people: an impish child, a caring doctor, a diligent policeman, a righteous judge, an unobtrusive servant. Yet Christie makes each of those the murderer at least once. She even uses her own stereotypes to fool us. Time and again we encounter the same character in her books, for example, the gruff military man returned from some distant outpost with his vocabulary reduced to “harrumph.” Christie pulls off the surprise ending when the figure she habitually uses for comic relief is revealed as the murderer. 

She also gives a twist to stereotypical situations like the eternal triangle. A married man with a wandering eye falls for a femme fatale while his long-suffering wife endures his neglect. The reader sees a familiar situation and assumes the wife will be the victim murdered by either the husband or the “other woman.” Dame Agatha usually dashes those expectations. If she wrote a version of Little Red Riding Hood, the wolf wouldn’t be the bad guy.
A man slumped in his char, surrounded by three other men and two women
The Usual Suspects
Sympathy

Christie leads us away from the correct solution by playing on our sympathies. A person subjected to poison pen letters, threats, or narrow escapes from death arouses compassion rather than suspicion. The surprise ending reveals the would-be victim as the murderer. 

We also sympathize with anyone who appears to seek truth and justice. The person who asks for the detective’s help in solving or preventing a murder sits at the bottom of the suspect list. Christie’s ultimate sleight of hand is making the murderer the character through whose eyes we view the action, the narrator. She pulled this off spectacularly in the book that made her reputation. But that wasn’t the only time she used this device.
​

Déjà Vu

The next time I read an Agatha Christie, I’ll watch out for the three S’s—Sidetracks, Stereotypes, and Sympathy. Even so, I probably won’t figure out whodunit.  As Robert Bernard writes in A Talent to Deceive, Christie can use the same trick “a second time and we are still deceived”--and entertained. 
Picture
Distress evokes sympathy--Image by Piyapong Saydaung from Pixabay
​More about Agatha Christie:
Try a trivia quiz about her weapons
Picture

    Contact Me

Submit
Vertical Divider
© 2023 Mary Ann Corrigan
​
​Legal Fine Print: Unless otherwise noted, I have purchased the rights to images on this site, the owner has granted free use of them, or they are in the public domain, the United States copyright having expired.
Newsletter Signup 
​
Subscribe to my seasonal newsletter for contests, discounts, and book news.
​I give away a book each time I send a newsletter. You can always unsubscribe. 
​​

powered by TinyLetter